Victorian Romance Emma: Why I Like It
Without knowing the actual story or characters to Emma, I was initially attracted to the series for two reasons: 1) the title was directed by Tsuneo Kobayashi (Super GALS!, Midori Days, Twelve Kingdoms); 2) it was a period piece.
Kaoru Mori, the creator of Victorian Romance Emma is a self-proclaimed Anglophile and her attempts to recreate late 1800s Victorian England have been universally praised for its accuracy and attention to detail. With that much research done, Tsuneo Kobayashi was also able to add his touch and expertise to put that vision in motion. Concerning those two factors, I was greatly satisfied. While I assumed it would be a romance story, I didn’t realize how well everything would be told and conveyed.
I like that its not only a love story that was handled well, but captured the varying mindsets of those in Victorian society; most leaning towards “this is unacceptable and wrong,” with some people becoming accepting of it. Even at the end of the show, we hear Richard Jones remark that this type of society and mindset is self-destructive and set to fail because of such arrogance like the Campbell’s.
Obviously, the biggest obstacle for the two leads, Emma and William Jones, would be the obvious class differences, so one of the big draws was to see how the love between the two would grow and play-out through the course of the show, wondering who would move first, and to see how the characters would deal with their feelings.
I really thought of Emma as a female lead that was as strong as she could be given the time period. I think she truly wanted change, not because it seemed to be natural because of her education and position within society, but because she really wanted to be with William and the differences between the two in that alone were too great for her to handle. I don’t believe she ever doubted that William did not have feelings for her; she just felt that she wasn’t worthy of him. William also didn’t feel that he was worthy of Emma and he set out to prove to himself that he was throughout the show (this is especially evident with the South American Railroad storyline, which at first I thought felt very tacked on, but when I realized that it served this purpose, I did feel that it was executed well.). In ways, I find William to be a character I can relate to in a number of ways. There is the feeling of being unsure when falling for someone, but there is also the person that lives in a world of expectations, but does things their own way.
The main item I found in their attitudes though was that they found it more important to prove themselves to be their idea of worthy to one another before proving themselves before society.
Hans was introduced in the second season and was the clear rival for Emma’s affections. Emma entertained the idea of being with him, in her moments of uncertainty and feeling that she was more on par in status with Hans, but even he ultimately realized that she never would have loved him like she loved William.
The role of Prince Hakim is interesting. Initially, you can tell he is brought in to be a rival to William; he becomes smitten with Emma immediately and doesn’t hesitate to act on those feelings. He infers that William is also interested in her and quickly takes the role of a foil. Hakim is more confident and a social butterfly (something Mr. Jones even notes), whereas William isn’t always sure of himself and is a bit childish. Hakim’s hastiness alone should make William look like a better choice to Emma to the viewer. Privately, Hakim helped serve as a motivator and someone who could urge William to take the risk and be with Emma. I think that he valued his friendship with William too much to want to complicate it by competing over Emma with him. When he took on this role, I think he also became the voice of the viewer that wanted to see the two be together in the end.
What I believe can be blanket-statement said is that these characters were portrayed and written very realistically and never came off as over-the-top (even Hakim when he would do something outlandish, it would be written off as “a foreign idea” since he was foreign himself).
There’s a level of quality that never seems to drop in the animation and overall design of the show that should be noted. Consciously using drab and muted colors in the town and using gaudy and excessive colors for the manors and balls. The intricate design in wallpaper and decorative pieces, as well as wardrobe (and its nice to see so many different clothing choices, not just because of the wide breadth of characters in the show, but specific individuals having many different pieces). Another stylistic choice that I liked was that many scenes and shots were not centered (except for some of the show’s more pivotal scenes).
Many techniques throughout the show also impressed me, such as very effective use of shadow and lighting. A short sequence involving the Joneses in front of a stained glass window is one of the most beautifully done and the fact that they were able to pan out while imitating a Victorian peep show/peep box was one of the most fascinating scenes I have ever seen in anime.
With such wonderfully written characters, beautiful animation and composition, attention to detail of the time, and a most fantastic soundtrack, it is easy for me to consider this one of my favorite shows.





























